刘雪红:法学博士,华东政法大学博士后。研究方向:国际经济法。
D996.1
国有企业是否具有私人投资者身份决定了国有企业可否诉请国际投资仲裁保护。ICSID对此采取宽松立场。投资保护协定传统上会通过投资者界定条款来解决对国有企业仲裁救济保护的问题,但新兴的双边和区域投资协定则通过“竞争中立”条款预先“塑造”国有企业的私人投资者身份。ICSID仲裁实践中采用的“商业活动检测法”也逐渐由低标准朝综合评判行为性质和目的等多元要素之高标准发展。ICSID相关的实践和发展趋向对中国国有企业参与国际投资活动和内部的改革具有重大启示意义。
That whether state-owned enterprises have the status of private investors is decisive for their availability to international investment arbitration. ICSID adopts a generous position on this issue. While investment protection agreements traditionally decide the availability of arbitration relief through investor-defined terms, the emerging bilateral and regional investment treaties promote the establishment of “private investor status” for state-owned enterprises through the rules of "competitive neutrality". The "commercial transaction test" adopted by ICSID practice is gradually developing from a low standard to a rigid one the judgement of which will comprehensively evaluate all relevant elements including the nature and purpose of activities concerned. The ICSID practice provides significant implications for the China's state-owned enterprises as to their participation of international investments and self-reform.
刘雪红.论国有企业私人投资者身份认定及启示——以ICSID仲裁申请人资格为视角*[J].上海对外经贸大学学报,2017,(3):5-16.
复制