陈咏梅:法学博士,西南政法大学教授,博士生导师。研究方向:国际经济法。
F713.36/F744
本文系2016年国家社科基金项目“《跨太平洋伙伴关系协定》创新及中国应对研究”(16XFX023)、2017年西南政法大学学生科研创新项目“跨境数据流动的国际规制研究”(2017XZXS-014))、2015年西南政法大学国际法学院科研创新项目“《跨太平洋伙伴关系协定》新议题研究”(2015T006)阶段性成果。
跨境数据流动的国际规制已逐渐成为新一轮双边、区域贸易谈判的新议题。美国极力倡导贸易数据的跨境自由流动,推动TPP成为第一个在“电子商务”章中纳入具有约束力的规制跨境数据流动的自由贸易协定,为未来贸易谈判提供了参考。而跨境数据流动国际规制面临各国数据本地化要求的障碍,主要表现为通过国内措施要求数据本地化存储并限制数据跨境流动。WTO规则和TPP协定在识别数据本地化要求中的合法公共政策目标和不合理贸易限制时,存在着适用上的不确定性及适用困难。文章认为,全球治理背景下跨境数据流动国际规制的未来路径,可以设计为在对数据进行分类的前提下,由各国通过谈判对分类数据加以承诺。中国则应当关注跨境数据流动国际规制的新发展,完善国内规制,并积极争取跨境数据流动国际规制的话语权。
International regulation-formulation in cross-border data flow has already gradually become a new subject in the new-round bilateral and regional trade negotiations. United States spares no effort to promote free flow of cross-border data flow enhancing TPP to be the first free-trade agreement, characterized by mandatory power that can regulate cross-border data flow, to be included in the chapter of “Electronic Commerce”. Thus, a model can be provided for the reference of future trade negotiations. However, international regulation-formulation of cross-border data flow faces the obstacle of data-localization requirements of the countries, featuring that domestic measures require local storage of data and confine cross-border flow of data. In identifying the legitimate public policy objective and irrational trade constraints in the requirements of data localization, WTO rules and TPP agreements have some uncertainties and difficulties in application. The paper supposes that, in the background of global governance, the future path of international regulation-formulation in cross-border data flow may be set as follows: with the prerequisite of data classification, the parties negotiate and make a commitment as for classified data. And China should pay attention to new development of international regulation-formulation in cross-border data flow, perfect domestic regulations and actively strive for discourse power of international regulation-formulation in cross-border data flow.
陈咏梅,张姣.跨境数据流动国际规制新发展:困境与前路*[J].上海对外经贸大学学报,2017,(6):37-52.
复制