毕莹:法学博士,浙江大学光华法学院副教授。研究方向:国际经济法,贸易与竞争,区域经济一体化。
D996.1
美国2012年投资协定范本第2条第2款(b)项规定了条约义务的主体包括“政治分支机构”,这一概念主要规定于美国《外国主权豁免法》(FSIA)。考察FSIA相关理论及判例发现,从一般定义看,“政治分支机构”系一种广义的概念,该词虽难以精确对应我国的行政区划,但可做出范围上的大致映射,即:所有的中央政府之下的政府性单位,既包括地方政府,诸如省、行政区、郡县、自治市等从属性政府实体,又在多数案例中包括中央的部门或部委。从除外规定看,在认定我国某一特定的行政区划实体是否属于“政治分支机构”时,可尝试通过证明自身为“代理机构”,从而抗辩其不属于条约义务承担主体。“政治分支机构”与“代理机构”具有水平联动与垂直联动两层关系,判断上存在法律特征标准与核心功能标准之别。
2012 US Model BIT stipulates that the subject of treaty obligations includes the "political subdivision", which is mainly stipulated in the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Law of the United States. The relevant legislative report points out that the "political subdivision" includes all the government units under the central government, including the local governments. The practice controversy focuses on how to distinguish between the "political subdivision" and "agency or instrumentality ". There are two criteria: “Legal Characteristics Test" and "Core Functions Test". In addition, defining whether an entity is a political subdivision will further influence the judgment of the organ of the entity or whether most of the shares or owners' interests are all entities.
毕莹.“政治分支机构”的概念及相关问题研究——以美国《外国主权豁免法》为背景*[J].上海对外经贸大学学报,2018,(5):53-62.
复制