厦门大学法学院,厦门 361005
韩秀丽:厦门大学法学院教授,博士生导师,厦门大学法学院非洲法与国际法研究中心主任。研究方向:国际法、非洲法。
张启扉:厦门大学法学院国际法专业博士研究生。研究方向:国际法、对外关系法。
D922.13
本文受国家社科基金重大专项(项目编号:21VGQ1013)的资助
School of Law, Xiamen University, Xiamen 361000 , China
《中华人民共和国外国国家豁免法》昭示着中国正式采取限制豁免制度,这符合中国的国家利益。同时,该法的实施关涉中非合作,并可能在未来给中非合作带来风险挑战。 因而,梳理非洲国家在外国法院的涉讼主体、涉讼事由、抗辩路径与诉讼结果,能够较全面地呈现非洲国家在外国涉讼的国家豁免问题,为我国处理以非洲国家为被告的案件提供样本参考。在我国豁免制度转型的背景下,我国需要处理好保障私主体权益、 尊重非洲国家的豁免权以及维护中非友好关系三者的平衡,针对非洲国家未来的在华涉讼可能,剖析国家豁免问题的潜在挑战并提出具体对策。
The “Foreign State Immunity Law of the People’s Republic of China” has now been implemented. This legislation marks China’s formal adoption of a restrictive immunity stance, aligning with the PRC’s current national interests. The implementation of this law is relevant to China-Africa cooperation and will present future risks and challenges. African states are prone to lawsuits in foreign courts. By examining the defendants, causes of actions, defense strategies, and outcomes in foreign courts, we can gain a comprehensive understanding of the state immunity issues faced by African states abroad, providing reference cases for handling lawsuits in China with African states as defendants. In the context of China’s transition to restrictive immunity, litigation involving African states in China poses several challenges: the potential disruption of individual lawsuits to China-Africa relations, political and diplomatic considerations undermining the predictability of the “Foreign State Immunity Law”, and obstacles to enforcing favorable verdicts for Chinese private entities due to the immunity from compulsory judicial measures under the law. In the context of China’s state immunity institutional transition, China needs to balance protecting private rights, respecting the immunity of African states, and maintaining friendly China-Africa relations. In view of the possible future litigation involving African states in China, China should properly analyze potential challenges regarding state immunity and propose specifi c countermeasures.
韩秀丽,张启扉.非洲国家在外国涉讼的国家豁免问题——基于中国国家豁免制度转型的思考[J].上海对外经贸大学学报,2025,32(3):110-124.
复制